Top 7 Best Ice Cream Maker Reviews and Guides

best compressor ice cream maker

This is my view on the current top 7 ice cream makers on the market today.  I review each of these in detail on the site, along with a wide range of additional reviews.  But these are my top 5 choices, based on the quality of the end product, ease of use and overall value for money.

1. Cuisinart ICE-21 Frozen Yogurt-Ice Cream & Sorbet Maker 

The Cuisinart ICE-21 makes a variety delicious treats. You can enjoy yummy, homemade frozen desserts from the comfort of your own home. As well as making yogurt, ice cream, and sorbet, this machine is also perfect for frozen drinks. With exceptionally easy clean up you will wonder why you ever settled for store-bought ice cream.

This is a fully automatic machine, which means absolutely no hassle for you. Just add your ingredients to the bowl, press on, and the machine does the rest. It takes just 20 minutes to create satisfying treats for your whole family. This is a no fuss, no mess unit that will exceed your expectations.

It is equipped with a wide range of features to ensure that you get delicious ice cream every time. With the ingredient spout you can also add extras like nuts and candy. The easy-lock lid is transparent and locks simply and effectively.

In addition the mixing paddle both mixes and aerates, while the freezer bowl guarantees fast and even freezing. It also has a heavy-duty motor that gives your frozen treat a smooth consistency. The rubber feet are nonslip to make sure that the Cuisinart ICE-21 remains stationary the entire time. Lastly, cord storage keeps your counter neat and safe.

These features combine to deliver an exceptional performance. You will love how easily you can make ice cream and desserts, and how great they taste.

Product Features

  • New mixing paddle makes frozen desserts and drinks in 20 minutes
  • Large capacity makes up to 1 ½ quarts
  • Double insulated freezer bowl eliminates the need for ice
  • Easy lock transparent lid with large spout makes adding ingredients simple and mess free
  • Fully automatic with large ingredient spout for adding ingredients

Customers Reviews

The Cuisinart ICE-21 Frozen Yogurt-Ice Cream & Sorbet Maker creates delicious treats for you and your family. It is easy to use and very quiet. In addition, it is exceptionally easy to clean. This virtually hassle-free product is a great purchase for almost anyone.

It makes ice cream and other frozen treats taste better than ever. This machine makes ice cream the perfect consistency and extremely smooth.

You can control the ingredients that go into your food and limit the amount of unhealthy additions you include. The fresh, pure taste this unit provides is unmatched in quality. Read More Customers Reviews

Review Summary

The only complaint that customers had was that it is a bit difficult to scoop ice cream or other treats out of the canister. Overall, reviewers were very impressed by just about everything. It delivers great results in no time at all; this is a product the whole family will enjoy.

If you are looking for a new way to enjoy ice cream and other frozen desserts, this unit produces wonderful results. Some people even claimed that is better than anything store bought.

The Cuisinart ICE-21 will exceed your expectations and have you enjoying fresh, delicious treats in no time at all.

2. Yonanas 902 Ice Cream Maker

Straight out the gate this is no ordinary ice cream maker as we review the Yonanas 902 Ice Cream Maker.  If you’re like me and love ice cream then you’re going to love the idea of frozen fruit ice cream for a healthy alternative to ice cream.  The machine turns any frozen fruit into a product that resembles the same texture as frozen yogurt and soft serve ice cream.  But with all the health benefits of fruit, which means you can surely eat this delicious treat more often.   It’s important that you know that the main ingredient that has to be used with the Yonanas 902 is bananas.  So right away of you or your family don’t like bananas then I wouldn’t recommend buying this product.

Product Details

  • Yonanas instantly turns frozen fruit and other flavorings into a delicious and healthy soft-serve treat.
  • The unit instantly churns the ingredients to produce a treat with the texture of frozen yogurt or soft-serve ice cream
  • The chute easily accepts berries, sliced mango, or cantaloupe along with frozen banana to incorporate the fruit into a silky-smooth confection
  • Yonanas Includes instructions and a list of recipes. Plugs into AC. 14″ H x 7 1/2″ W x 6″ D.
  • The chute, plunger, and blade are dishwasher safe

Customer Reviews

Despite its strange appearance this machine does what it says on the box, and will make a great healthy alternative to ice cream.  We found the machine to be very loud when in use and this is the biggest problem that everyone seems to complain about with this product.

Its not just a banana masher, it actually changes the texture of the banana and makes a creamy paste that has the same consistency as frozen ice cream.  Its a great way to make sure that your eating your daily amount of fruit, and kids simply love the taste from this.

Preparation time can be a pain so make sure that you have a lot of frozen fruit in your freezer at all times.  Cleaning the machine is easy, all of the parts are dish washer safe, and can simply be dismantled and washed in warm soapy water.

Its fast becoming a top selling product and its easy to understand why with the amazing health and life benefits of fresh fruit. Read More Customers Reviews

Video Review

You also need to know that you need plenty of time to prepare the ingredients for this machine, and don’t expect to be able just to whip something together in five minutes.  Your bananas must be ripe, peeled and then frozen for 24-hours prior to use.  And any additional frozen fruit that you also want to add to your mix needs to be prepared in the same way.  Then you need to thaw them for about 5-minutes also prior to use.  Its really important to make sure that the fruit is thawed out properly or this could easily lead to burning the motor out.  Your going to need 4 bananas if your not mixing any other fruit, which should feed 2 people.  Fire the machine up and simply place your fruit into the top of the product, then using the plunger push the fruit into the product.  Once all of your fruit has gone through the machine, simply mix it up to ensure a consistent blend.  We found that a lot of the mixture was left behind in the machine and its best to remove this before you clean the product up.

Review Summary

The Yonanas 902 makes a delicious healthy alternative to home or factory made ice cream and at a fraction of the cost compared to ice cream.

The Yonanas 902 ice cream maker is a great addition to any kitchen, it makes something very close to soft serve ice cream that is incredibly nutritional and creamy in texture.  We loved this product and scored it a very respectful 4 out of 5 for the Yonanas 902 ice cream maker.

3. Nostalgia Electrics ICMP-400 Electric Ice Cream

The Nostalgia Electrics ICMP-400 BLUE 4-Quart Electric Ice Cream Maker makes homemade ice cream without the inconvenience of old-fashioned technology.  All you have to do is fill the aluminum canister with your ingredients, fill the plastic bucket with ice, place the canister in center of the ice, and let the machine do the work for you.  The result is fresh, delicious, homemade ice cream.

What The Nostalgia Electrics ICMP-400 Electric Ice Cream Maker Offers?

This product is the most convenient way to make fresh, homemade ice cream.  People have been making ice cream at home for centuries.  The first machines consisted of a wooden bucket with a crank craven mixer, and used a combination of salt and ice to lower the temperature of the ingredients.  \There are also a couple of ways to make ice cream without using a machine, but these methods take hours before you have anything close to resembling soft serve ice cream.

Homemade ice cream is a special treat, and the Nostalgia Electrics ICMP-400BLUE 4-Quart Electric Ice Cream Maker makes it easy.  Instead of a process that takes half of your day to complete, this machine makes it possible to serve your own ice cream recipes in 30 minutes or less!  That’s it.

Follow a couple of simple steps, and you too can make fresh, all natural ice cream in your own home.  No preservatives or fillers, and no artificial colors.  Just, fresh, delicious ice cream your family will crave for in minutes.

Product Features

The Nostalgia Electrics ICMP-400 BLUE 4-Quart Electric Ice Cream Maker uses some very simple features to help you make perfect homemade ice cream.

  • A 4 qt. Aluminum canister for holding and mixing the ingredients
  • A plastic bucket to hold the ice and salt, and a plastic dasher
  • An electric motor for churning the ingredients into yummy ice cream
  • Easy to read instruction manual with several homemade ice cream recipes
  • This ice cream maker is as easy to clean as it is to use

What Customers Are Saying

Customers agree that this is a GREAT ice cream maker.  Currently priced at under $30, the Nostalgia Electrics ICMP-400 BLUE 4-Quart Electric Ice Cream Maker is an excellent value.  There are several machines on the market right now that cost hundreds of dollars. For a fraction of those prices, you can get an inexpensive and dependable machine that makes ice cream which tastes just as good as if it was made in a $300 machine.

Customers who choose to review this product on line have given it exceptionally high marks.  It is dependable, light weight, and easy to use.  The older wooden bucket ice cream makers are help together with brass bands.  Numerous reports indicate that these bands are prone to rust and corrosion due to contact with salt water.  This plastic machine does not have that problem.  The 4 quart capacity is quite large enough for most customers to make enough ice cream for the entire family and then some.  If you would like to read some more reviews on this Nostalgia Electrics ICMP-400 product, then all you need to do is Click this Button here.

The product is advertised as making ice cream in 30 minutes.  This ice cream will be soft, not the hard kind you are used to getting at the store or local ice cream shop.  It is real homemade ice cream.  If you like hard frozen ice cream, the process will take longer.  But, the results will be fantastic! Read More Customers Reviews

Highly Recommended

Manufacturers can make all the claims they want, but customer reviews will reveal how a product actually performs.  This ice cream maker, according to reviews, is fantastic.   It makes delicious soft ice cream in about 30 minutes.

It is remarkably inexpensive in comparison to other ice cream makers that are not nearly as convenient, and makes ice cream that is just as delicious.

And, it comes with a 90-day warranty for defects in workmanship or materials.  Great ice cream in less time with the Nostalgia Electrics ICMP-400,  Delicious.

4. White Mountain F69206-X Reviews

White Mountain has been helping families make delicious ice cream since the 1850s. It has played an important role in helping people everywhere reconnect and enjoy the tradition of making smooth, creamy ice cream. They are renowned for their high-quality and durable products and this unit is no exception. This is a fast and easy way to satisfy your ice cream craving and create a longstanding family tradition.  It works extremely fast, and in just twenty to forty minutes you can be enjoying the fresh taste of homemade ice cream. This unit maintains the longstanding tradition of homemade flavor. It is a great way to create memories that you will cherish for years to come.

This ice cream maker is equipped with a variety of well-made and designed features. The motor is commercial grade and delivers great results every time. In addition, the bucket is crafted from New England pine for lasting stability. The canister and dasher are also very durable and easy to use. This unit will not wear out with time.

With is powerful electric motor and steel inner bucket; this ice cream maker is one of the best available on the market today. Most importantly, is has a corrosion-resistant, cast iron, triple-action dasher that delivers professional results. It comes with a five-year warranty for your additional peace of mind. This is a great addition to any home, and will make enough ice cream to satisfy any size gathering or party.

Product Features

  • Makes 6 quarts of ice cream, frozen yogurt, or other frozen confection
  • Electric motor makes traditional family fun easier
  • Stainless-steel freezer can and dasher inside wooden tub
  • Recipes included
  • White mountain ice cream maker
  • Freezer can and dasher are dishwasher safe

Product Reviews

Customers were very impressed by the White Mountain Electric Ice Cream Freezer. It is very simple to operate and gets great results. This is a high-quality product that is backed by years of service. It is an important part of the longstanding tradition of making homemade ice cream for you and your family.

This unit lasts an exceptionally long time; many reviewers had owned their White Mountain for over twenty years. Although it is a bit more expensive than smaller models, it is definitely worth every penny for the durability you receive. It takes no time at all to make firm, delicious ice cream.

The only real complaint is that this unit is a bit noisy. This is to be expected with such a large model and did not bother most people. In addition, some customers were disappointed that is only came with a few recipes. It was recommended that your purchase an additional recipe book for more variety.

Click here to Read more reviews

Review Summary

Simply put, this ice cream maker is superior to all other models. You will not find this kind of quality or durability anywhere else. It is designed for easy clean up, which reviewers really appreciated. In addition, leftovers stay fresh and delicious in the freezer.

Your family will love using the White Mountain Electric Ice Cream Freezer and because of this we highly recomend the White Mountain F69206-X for any family.

5.Cuisinart ICE-50BC Supreme Ice Cream Maker

The Cuisinart ICE-50BC Supreme Ice Cream Maker is a professional machine that delivers incomparable results. This is a great addition to any home and is sure to impress your family and friends. With this product, you can customize your favourite frozen desserts for delicious results. This exceptional and multifunctional unit is a fun and enjoyable way to satisfy any craving.

This ice cream maker is extremely easy to use. You simply have to add your ingredients, set the timer, and the machine takes care of the rest. It works faster than almost any other comparable product and in less than an hour your can enjoy your favorite frozen treat. This is perfect for parties and events because there is no waiting time between batches.

Even if you have never made your own ice cream before you will be able to make delicious creations. This is a one-step operation that is exceptionally easy. Pre-freezing is not required and this unit requires very little preparation to deliver amazing results. It mixes efficiently and consistently to make sure every batch is perfect.

It is equipped with a wide range of features to ensure easy operation. This unit has a large ingredient spout so that you can add your favorite mix-ins. Its transparent lid with opening is especially designed so that you can add extra ingredients while the ice cream maker is working. Most importantly, it has a built-in compressor and precise temperature control.

It has a heavy-duty, built-in powerful motor that you will not find anywhere else. The Cuisinart ICE-50BC Supreme Ice Cream Maker is created for professional performance and perfect results every single time. This is a great way to add excitement to your next birthday party, picnic, or barbecue.


  • Fully automatic 1 ½ quart frozen yogurt, sorbet, and ice cream maker
  • Brushed stainless steel housing; commercial style compressor freezer; pre-freezing not required
  • Precise temperature control and efficient mixing; fully automatic 60-minute timer
  • Ingredient spout; lid, paddle, and bowl remove for easy washing; instruction and recipe book included
  • Limited 3-year warranty

Cuisinart ICE-50BC Supreme Ice Cream Maker Reviews

This exceptional machine delivers excellent results that thoroughly impressed customers. This is a well-made unit that can satisfy a wide variety of needs. If you are looking for an easy way to make fresh, delicious treats, this is the perfect unit for you. Reviewers agree that this is a great addition to any home.

Review Summary

A few customers complained about the noise level. Luckily, this machine is fully automatic so you can leave the room while it does the work for you. In addition, although the majority of the machine is stainless steel, the arm that drives the churn is plastic and one reviewer claimed that it broke.

However, the reviews were generally positive for this unit. The Cuisinart ICE-30BC is easy to set up and is less messy than other models. In addition, its base is heavy and sturdy so that you will not have to worry about leakage.

The is a great product that will exceed your expectations.

6. Lello 4080 Musso Lussino Ice Cream Maker 

The Lello 4080 Musso Lussino Ice Cream Maker simply creates the most delicious frozen treats that you will ever experience. It is made in Italy and is designed for competitive performance and outstanding results. Although it is more expensive than other brands, there is no comparison in quality. This ice cream maker is far superior to any other model available.

It can be used to make a variety of treats including ice cream, sorbet, frozen yogurt, and frozen drinks. This is a great addition to any home and is something that your family and friends will enjoy for years to come. It takes only 30 minutes to make delicious and pure frozen desserts. This is a professional model that will exceed your expectations.

The Lello 4080 is precisely controlled for exceptional results. It is the most efficient way to satisfy your ice cream craving. Pre-freezing is not required so you can immediately make another batch once your first one is finished. This makes your desserts perfectly every time. If the batch becomes to hard the machine automatically shuts off to preserve the quality of your ice cream.

It is made of stainless steel for sanitation and easy cleaning. An instruction booklet and recipes are included. It comes with a one-year warranty for your additional peace of mind. This is a great purchase that will exceed all of your expectations. It is a perfect choice for any ice cream lover.


  • 1 ½ quart capacity bowl freezes 3 quarts of ice cream or sorbet per hour
  • Fully automatic: pour ingredients into bowl, press two buttons
  • Timer controls operation for different frozen confections
  • Housing, bowl, paddle made of stainless steel for easy cleaning
  • 1-year warranty

Customers Reviews

This Ice Cream Maker is an excellent and efficient way to make frozen treats the whole family will love. It is simple to use and does a great job every single time. This is a durable unit that will not wear out over time; it will be an enjoyable part of your life for years to come. Customers also love its design and how aesthetically pleasing it is.

This is a fun way to get creative. It is absolutely no fuss, you don’t need ice, salt, or pre-frozen bowls to make delicious frozen treats. This is perfect for an average family, and can easily make enough for parties and gatherings.

The one complaint customers had was that it is a bit difficult to clean. The bowl isn’t removable so it can be a bit awkward to get at. Although it is more expensive than other models, it is worth every penny. This ice cream maker is the best model you will ever buy. Read more Customers Reviews

Review Summary

Many reviewers claimed that is makes the best ice cream that they had ever tasted.

This machine lasts an exceptionally long time. In addition, it is extremely quiet and will not disturb you in the least. The Lello 4080 Musso Lussino is a very capable machine that is sure to impress.

7. Lello Musso Pola 5030

Homemade ice cream is all the rage right now, with unique flavors and a personal touch for dessert time while entertaining. If you have certain dietary restrictions like diabetes or lactose intolerance, or are joining the fitness craze to improve your personal health, purchasing a ready-made frozen dessert will throw you off your mark.  Sometimes having a treat can be hard.

Well, why not make your own ice cream and frozen dessert dishes with the Lello Musso Pola 5030 Desert Maker?

With only 20 minutes of time, this Italian machine can make two quarts of frozen desserts. In one hour it will make a gallon and a half of creamy sugar free ice cream or sorbet. The Italians are known for rich and creamy gelato, so create your own delicious recipes right in your kitchen every night instead of pining for it or spending money going out for a small portion.

This Lello Musso Pola 5030 machine also can make fruity sorbets, rich American ice cream and intoxicating frozen drinks. The machine has a freezing unit that does not require salt or ice, meaning no other items are needed for running it. This equates to a clean mess-free kitchen, simple and easy!

Product Features:

  • Two-quart capacity
  • Can make frozen treats in 20 minutes
  • Stainless steel casing
  • Durable
  • Classic, clean look
  • Made in Italy

Product Reviews

Many of the reviewers said this dessert maker is worth the high price tag. If you could afford it, get it, many said. The ice cream really does come out in 20 minutes and it is delicious, they said, as authentic in flavor and texture as if they were overseas in Italy and stepped into a gelato shop.

Many said this machine is fool proof, and one reviewer said the Lello Musso Pola was a favorite among their students at a culinary arts school. The ease of use was praised continually as it is a simple mix and pour system.  This product shines when used to create personal family recipes.  There is no conversion necessary to try to adapt to the modern technology, as opposed to the old fashioned crank ice cream freezer. Read More Customers Reviews

Review Summary

One reviewer had mentioned a tip to buyers: Purchase some reading material in the form of novelty cookbooks that feature desserts. This person said if a dessert machine is purchased, then get an ice cream and frozen treats cookbook or two, to get ideas and have recipes readily available as the purchaser gets used to the new cooking device.

For diabetics or persons on a sugar free diet, adding instant pudding mix to the ice cream mixture will provide flavoring and a thickening agent.  It will also add the correct sweetness and the only other ingredient to add is cream.  This will not produce a hard ice cream; the resulting ice cream will be more like soft serve that is so popular at carnivals and fairs. If you use the sugar free pudding with a lactose free product like soy milk, it should produce a sherbet texture instead of a creamy texture.  It might harden more but this recipe has not been tested according to the suggestion from the consumer.

The Lello Musso Pola 5030 Desert Maker is a well-built and durable product that is highly recommended by professional chefs and home cooks alike.

Not happy with our selection?


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here